A Shocking Revelation: Colin Montgomerie Challenges Rory McIlroy Over Caddie Controversy

Colin Montgomerie has ignited a heated debate by challenging Rory McIlroy’s decision-making and the involvement of his caddie, Harry Diamond, in the devastating conclusion that cost McIlroy the US Open title at Pinehurst No. 2.

Montgomerie believes that Diamond should have played a more decisive role in preventing McIlroy’s heartbreaking loss. The Northern Irishman was on the brink of ending a ten-year major title drought but faltered with two critical missed putts on the 16th and 18th holes, allowing Bryson DeChambeau to clinch victory by a single shot.

The Controversial Decision

The criticism of Diamond centers on the choice to use a driver on the 18th hole, deviating from the 3-wood McIlroy had employed in the previous three rounds. This decision resulted in McIlroy pulling his tee shot left into a native area, complicating his approach to the green.

Despite executing a solid chip to give himself a chance at par, McIlroy’s four-foot downhill putt slid agonizingly past the cup, marking his third bogey in the final four holes. This missed opportunity not only cost him the title but also ignited a firestorm of criticism towards his caddie.

Montgomerie’s Strong Words

Montgomerie didn’t mince words in his critique. “He hadn’t [used the driver on 18] all week, and the caddie should have stopped him,” Montgomerie told The Times. He emphasized that DeChambeau was missing fairways consistently on Sunday, turning it into a long-drive competition. The luck favored DeChambeau, but not McIlroy.

Nick Faldo, during commentary, echoed Montgomerie’s sentiments, suggesting that this loss could haunt McIlroy for the rest of his life if he doesn’t secure another major title. Montgomerie shared the same sentiment, admitting that he felt more empathy for McIlroy than for DeChambeau that night.

Responses from the Golf Community

Tiger Woods’ former coach Hank Haney and golf channel pundit Smylie Kaufman also questioned Diamond’s decisions during the closing stretch. However, McIlroy didn’t hold back when addressing these critiques at The Renaissance Club, deeming them unfair. He pointed out that Haney has never been in that position, and Kaufman has experienced it only once. McIlroy emphasized that just because Diamond isn’t vocal doesn’t mean he doesn’t contribute significantly.

McIlroy’s Defense and Swift Exit

McIlroy also faced criticism for his quick departure after DeChambeau’s victory, opting not to stay and congratulate the winner. However, Montgomerie, who captained McIlroy during the 2010 Ryder Cup, defended McIlroy’s actions, calling them dignified. He related McIlroy’s feelings to his own experience at the 2006 US Open at Winged Foot, understanding the profound sense of letting down oneself and others.

 

In conclusion, the debate over McIlroy’s US Open heartbreak has sparked intense discussion within the golf community. Montgomerie’s critique has added fuel to the fire, challenging both McIlroy’s decisions and Diamond’s role in the heartbreaking loss.